Title credit to Ms Kimberly Clark; talented Drag Artiste, social activist and one of those few YouTubers who aren’t afraid speak their minds. She is bloody funny too.
Warning: Rather long post. Skip below to which ever product you are interested in. I am not going to buy 11 products. 1.the Bobbi Brown Setting Powder, 2. the ELF under-eye setting powder, 3. Lancome Grandiose Mascara, 4. Bobbi Brown Shimmer Blush, 5. Loreal Infallible Paints Eyeliner Pen, 6. Loreal Infallible Liquid Eyeshadow, 7. Mac Bronzer, 8. Mac Lip Prep and Prime, 10. Estee Lauder Little Black Primer and 11. Becca Champagne Pop highlighter.
Note: All my observations are via a x5 magnified mirror because that’s the only mirror I use to apply my makeup thanks to aging eyes 🙂
My project pan journey started March 2018 (post) . Using a product over and over again on different days, at different times, under different circumstances helped me understand what I really want out of each product. What I like about it, what I don’t and why.
I have reached a level of zero tolerance where I want a product to perform exactly how I expect it to irrespective of when and how I wear it. Otherwise I am not gonna buy it. (not including user error or using a sweaty hike as an example of performance :))
What I am not gonna buy (re-purchase);
Bobbi Brown Finishing Powder in Warm Natural & ELF Undereye Setting Powder
I love the ever widening pan, go me!
I usually powder to set my under-eyes, on my t-zone and along the sides of my nose. The rare occasion I have used to set my entire face I have to spritz MAC Fix plus to reduce the powdery effect.
I like it because of its blurring effect on my forehead lines and the pores on my cheeks. Under my eyes ? Not so much. It accentuates the lines under my eyes.
Now I like this product and would recommend it to people but for me personally;
- I don’t want to use a powder I have to spritz down. I want ease of use. One step and done!
- I don’t want a powder that accentuates the lines under my eyes. This is either a new thing with my advancing age or I have just noticed it. Either ways, nah.
- And lastly I want to own only 1 setting powder at any given time. Not have a mattifying one and another one thats a different formula on days I don’t want to use a spritz. It adds to clutter and an extra product I will struggle to ‘pan’.
So this I will not re-purchase, but what will I buy instead ?
I have a mini Laura Mercier Translucent setting powder I received as a sample that I will start on once I have panned Ms Brown.
However I am dreading the whole ‘sieve-powder’ hoopla that I have to go through with the Laura Mercier one.(Seriously how lazy of a makeup lover am I?)
By the time I am ready to buy another setting powder I would like to invest in something like the Becca Hydra Mist powder that is supposed to be 50% water and glycerine. But I am hoping they bring out a pressed powder version by then, I am so over this salt shaker bs.
The ELF undereye setting powder, the darling of many on the net, is not coming back either. Why ?
- I don’t like the micro glitter in it. While great for the under-eye not great for the other areas of my face.
- It accentuates the fine lines under my eye and
- I don’t like the whole sieve-powder malarkey, too tedious.
Lancome Grandiose Smudgeproof
I don’t like mascaras that are too wet and clump lashes together. In the picture it might look good but in real life, I had to brush through with a lash comb everytime I applied it, and I still wasn’t happy.
I don’t want 7 clumps of lashes, I want a full fluffy effect. Just for reference I love Benefit Bad Gal, Dior Icoinic, Chanel Inimitable (not de Volume; too wet for me) and Charlotte Tilbury’s Full Fat Lashes.
Oh…see the smudge-proof in the name ? well it….smudges. That’s my first beef with it.
Loreal Infallible Paints Eyeliner Pen & Liquid Eyeshadow
I am sorry both these are duds for me.
The Eyeliner pen is a hard felt tip which on my crepey eyelids skips and makes for a very jumpy line. Also it tends to go ‘translucent’ on me, not the solid black I was expecting. And it dries really fast on the lids, even before you have finished lining the entire lashline, so going back to smoothen out a skipped patch or smoothen out a rough line just removes the colour you have laid down in the first sweep.
And…it transfers onto my eye crease. Every time. I powder my lids and it still migrates. I have oily lids that are hooded to boot. The struggle is real.
The good news is the pen doesn’t dry out quickly. I started to store it nib side down from almost the 5th day I bought it and avoided the quick drying out that a lot of these type of pens seems to succumb too. I bought it last year and it’s still going.. …alas….
The eyeshadow paints are just not working for me.
- It looks like curdled cottage cheese on my eyelids. I think the glitter might be too chunky for someone with my crepey lids. Definitely not the rich wet sheen I had expected out of them.
- It applies well with my Real Techniques (synthetic) shading brush but my fingers give the best, uniform, coverage. However this could be a fat fingers v/s tiny eyelid space thing, but the shadow spreads all over, ie beyond my mobile lid, so there is shimmer all over my lids.
- The shade Cool Ivory applies translucent over my natural deep skin tone and needs a second layer. While they can be built up very well, you need to wait for each layer to dry before the next one and I can’t be bothered with that.
I expect liquid eyeshadows to be a wet-sheen like finish that can be achieved with a quick swipe and slight buffing around the edges.
The Loreal worn alone or buffed out with a matte shadow, looks dated because the shimmer travels all over the lid.
Remember when all eyeshadows were either satin or shimmery and looked awful on the lid because it emphasised every crease and made the eyes look bulgy ? ugh.
Bobbi Brown Shimmer Blush in Pink Sugar
Great blush, very pigmented with very very fine shimmer. I mean it’s Bobbi Brown I wouldn’t expect anything as crass as big chunks of glitter. 🙂
Once I am done with this one I am not gonna re-purchase because I now prefer mattes so I can place my highlighter on the specific areas I want to highlight, rather than the whole cheek.
But even without the shimmer I would not re-purchase because this is very pigmented, something I love in eye shadows but do not appreciate in blushes.
I lightly tap my brush in the pan, wipe it on the back of my hand and then apply it on my cheeks. Even then I am feverishly blending it out and finishing that off by buffing my setting powder over it. I like a flush effect and this takes a lot of work to where I am comfortable with the look.
Weirdly I prefer low pigment blushes so I can be rough and tumble and rest assured, whether I blend or not, I wont have clown cheeks.
MAC Bronzer and MAC Lip Prep and Prime
I have seen the gorgeous effect of a bronzer on people. Instant fab! Sadly not for me.
Bronzers rarely do anything for me or at-least I can’t see it. Contouring powders on the other hand, I can see their effect especially my favourite, Benefit’s Hoola.
I am a WOC with a NC 40 skintone and have a yellow undertone. For me, in order to look healthy and glowy it’s more about exfoliation, hydration, moisturisation and SPF. Add to that an under-eye concealer, a rich lip balm, dab on some highligher and done ! Kajal or mascara; optional.
When my face goes ‘flat’ after foundation I prefer to add the contours back with a matte contour powder.
This MAC bronzer is a beautiful neutral brown, imparts a natural ‘glow’ because of the fine micro shimmer it contains and would work wonders for someone else.
For me not only can I not tell the difference it’s making I don’t like the all over glow-y look. As always I prefer adding highlighter only over very specific areas of my face and not the larger areas this bronzer hits.
This bronzer is in my project pan and when….oh lord when?…I finish it I will not be re-purchasing. But I wont be buying the Hoola either.
I don’t really ‘contour’ that much and for when I do, I will simply use one of the many brown matte eyeshadows I have lying around.
And once those powders/eyeshadows are done, I will re-purchase the Hoola, the mini one ofcourse!
The MAC Lip Prep and Prime. Another product I am not sure I can see or tell what the product is doing for me. I know what it is supposed to do because I have read the marketing info and the instructions but IRL not worth the price for me.
Estee Lauder Little Black Primer and Becca Champagne Pop highlighter (pressed).
I received the Estee Lauder Little Black Primer as a gift and I LOVED it. I would still recommend it.
On no makeup days I would wear just that! It gave my lashes definition and didn’t smudge, even in Hong Kong’s 90% heat and humidity!
However worn under a mascara I couldn’t really tell the effect or rather it did not make such a huge difference.
Would I re-purchase once I am done with it ? Probably not.
In this past year or so my whole mascara attitude has changed. I have become mascara brash. I want my lashes to scream ” I am wearing full fat fluffy lashy mascara”.
And on those ‘natural days’ I could just as easily wear a mascara from the drugstore that doesn’t do it’s job and merely coats the lashes. (We know a lot of mascaras like that don’t we ?)
And drugstore is a heck of a lot cheaper than Estee Lauder. I am not comparing formulas here because the EL is uhmazing rather the effect it has on me or how I want to use it.
“Oh Becca Champagne Pop pressed powder. I am not impressed by you and I think it might be me and not you.”
I was expecting it to be sheen-y. In my x5 magnifying mirror I can see micro glitter that clings to my skin and peach fuzz and I don’t like it.
Also I am not into the ‘I have highlighter on’ look. I am more the ‘oh look at her inner glow’ type of person. 🙂
Right now the ONLY highlighters I like are the Hourglass Ambient Lighting powders.
and if they change their formula I will weep.
And if for some horrible reason they are not available anymore I will probably re-purchase the ELF blushed gems. Yes. Read my review here
So that’s it, enough rambling……back to panning …..so I can be free of these.